Lockdown news coverage - at CBC Vancouver the reporting has fallen to a 'Grade 8' English Level

I rarely consult the CBC Vancouver website, but I do study propaganda, and knowledge begins with research. CBC websites are obvious locations to bag juicy Canadian variants for the stew-pot. As a Public Historian I feel an obligation to collect a sampling of government produced propaganda texts and videos. After all,  it is conceivable that a minuscule fraction of future Canadians may become curious about the Great Covid-19 Scare of 2020-2023. I only archive material that is certain to be deleted, redacted, concealed by corporate algorithms, or conveniently "lost". Some information from our first year of lock-downs and travel restriction in British Columbia, has already vanished. The covert deletion of the public record (when it is kept at all) is just one of many consequences of embracing digital communication, and pretending that it is a natural step in our cultural evolution.  

In fact our culture is almost dead.  That statement is unacceptable to most Canadians, and I would not dare to make it myself. I leave that to an expert - Israeli psychologist Sam Vaknin. He recently posted a video to Youtube which is a gift to the ungrateful -   "SILENCE WHEN WE ARE ALL GONE".  Horrifying!

 Back to the CBC, and still on topic -  the destruction of our culture.  This morning I went the CBC  Vancouver website looking for a specific piece of information. Something else caught my eye. It was a photograph of an anti-lockdown demonstration held on March 1st. (see below) A protester is shown lofting a photograph of Dr. Bonnie Henry with a Pinocchio nose. That essentially Henry as a liar. That didn't bother me, because of course Bonnie does deceive from time to time. She has to, to get the population to obey dictates that often illogical and illegal.

What really disturbed more, was the article written by Alex Migdal.  I invite you to read this sample (below).  Do you consider that journalism?  Doesn't the story read like it is written for children?  I thought so, and I scraped the first five "paragraphs" (should I apologize for using sneer quotes?) and carried them over to an online tool that I often use to help students with their writing assignments. It is called the AUTOMATIC READABILITY CHECKER. It works by processing the sample with seven widely known readability formulas, and then establishing an average grading.

 

This is how the web-tool "graded" Mr.  Migdal's writing:

According to official federal statistics, Canada has a 99% literacy rate.  Have I not just shown you evidence that the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation believes our nation to be illiterate? A Grade 8 proficiency in English is NOT the the profile of a literate Canadian. 

The profile given for Mr. Migdal on the CBC web page claims - "He's previously reported for The Globe and Mail, Guelph Mercury and Edmonton Journal." So what happened to him? Now before you dismiss the significance of what I am bringing to your attention, I urge you to take the time to listen to Sam Vaknin's despairing report. My prediction is that when you have finished those 39 painful minutes, you must agree that Covid mania is just a symptom of a wasting condition that is probably fatal. 

If you take the trouble to find out how the employees of the CBC view their responsibility as guardians of our National Culture and their duty to make truthful statements about the taxpayers who fund their pay, perks and pensions... you need go no further than the "Journalistic Standards and Practices" page.

Under the header "Language Level and Good Taste" we find this defiant statement:  "We use the language of accessible, articulate everyday speech."  Of course they do.

 

COVID-19 Deaths in Burnaby and Vancouver Seniors Lodges - "the Little Mountain Disaster"

A TALE OF TWO NURSING HOMES

41 Dead at Little Mountain Place, Vancouver

29 Dead at Harmony Court, Burnaby

Because we are sentimental creatures, our smartphones are crammed with photographs. Only a very few record dramatic moments in our lives, because those events occur too quickly for us to even think in terms of pictures. Strange it is that, during this "greatest of modern pandemics" we are surrounded by intensely dramatic situations, and yet nobody is "getting the shot".  Our cities have been stricken by incidents of mass-death, yet these horrible dramas are played out in veiled secrecy. Who benefits?

On Wednesday I read a startling report that described the emergency vaccination of all survivors living and working at Little Mountain Place, a Vancouver nursing home. In total, 41 residents have died of COVID-19  during an outbreak that has lasted six weeks.  I hasten to add that 41 fatalities is a B.C. Provincial record - the largest number of COVID deaths at a single location. 

Equally startling was the comment of reporter Mike Howell (20 years of experience) who was, naturally, reluctant to enter a 'Hot Zone' that Provincial Health Officer Dr. Bonnie Henry had described as being "incredibly lethal".  Howell wrote that, "Over the span of two hours, no residents or staff were visible in the many windows of the care home, which still has a Christmas tree visible in its lobby and a string of lights across the entrance way."  Finally, the executive director of the facility emerged and dismissed the curious reporter by stating that all questions should be directed to Vancouver Coastal Health.

As it happens, one of my New Year's resolutions was to re-activate this news blog, and devote personal resources in 2021 to gathering facts and stories about what the Flu Pandemic and its bed-partner, the "Great Reset" promises to inflict upon our community, our nation, and our world.  In that spirit, on Thursday morning, after gym, I set out for Little Mountain to see things for myself.

 

Cold Reality in a Covid Hot Zone

Little Mountain Place - 421 confirmed dead at Care Home

330 East 36th Ave. (at Walden St.) Vancouver,  116 room facility

My primary goal was to acquire my own set of photos, and form my own impressions of the site.  On Thursday at noon,  I found Little Mountain Place just as Mike Howell had left it. Not a single employee in sight. Not a single resident peeking out a window!  I assumed that the 41 bodies had been removed, one by one, via the loading ramp at the back, so I started there. Birds were chirping, and a lone male jogger passed by, sans mask.  Moving to the fenced west-side of the property, nothing disturbed my shooting save for the distant snarl of a carpenter's sabre saw. Finally I drove around the block, past Cartier Park (a few mothers with toddlers in hand) and proceeded to the front of the care home. 

As I stood at the front of "L.M.P." contemplating the bizarre juxtaposition of horror narratives with a sleepy, nondescript streetscape,  I suddenly realized what bothered me.  This was a building where 99 of the residents had been infected (41 died) and 70 staff infected. They are still dealing with virulent contagion inside, and there is no health warning posted. L.M.P. is nestled in a very populous neighbourhood,  with condos and detached homes all around.  There is no security guard on the door, no cautionary tape, no warning posters - or anything that might hint of a viral Hot Zone. This is nothing short of a callous disregard for the neighbouring families, compounded by the fact that, as was recently exposed, L.M.P. staff and the local authority (Vancouver Coastal Health) had been suppressing information about the scale and scope of the outbreak. More on that later.

Until now I had only known of Little Mountain Place through friends who are members of the Taiwanese charity  Tzu Chi Foundation Canada.  Taiwanese volunteers often visit and donate funds to assist L.M.P., though the residents (and many of the 41 dead) are Cantonese speaking Chinese.

On Friday at noon, I photographed the front-half of AgeCare Harmony Court, which is located near the busy intersection of Canada Way and Edmonds.  Harmony Court bears the unhappy distinction of ranking highest in COVID Flu deaths among the many seniors complexes operating in Burnaby.  Since November 19th  a total of 29 residents have died, and there again we have the cold reality of hidden horrors. All passing pedestrians are oblivious to the ghastly events that have been endured by residents and staff alike. As you can see for yourself, (photo) there is not the slightest public notification of the health crisis inside.  No security, no warning posters, nothing.  

I can guarantee that if secrecy were abandoned, and the public not treated like fools, good-hearted people would have lain flowers outside, or could perhaps give a cheery wave to any frightened resident who appeared at the window.  Some of the details of these epidemic deaths emerged a week ago, but I am not convinced it is common knowledge. Most people I know gave up on watching "the Bonnie and Adrian show" long ago, and pay little attention to news reports.

MASS DEATH and MASS MEDIA

Our province and our country have been held captive for almost a year by the Corona-virus and by  governments that immediately imposed a hybrid form of Medical Martial Law.  We all placed our trust in figurehead leadership, and Her Majesty's Loyal Opposition in Ottawa, and in all ten Canadian provinces, stood down. Never in the history of Canada has government been totally spared of a single dissenting voice in the Legislature or the news media. In such a no-threat environment, even a bunny rabbit would grow complacent.  

Little Mountain Place may be managed by  a "non-profit society" but have no doubt that it is run by the Province. It has 116. single-occupancy rooms for which each resident pays 80% of their annual net income (ie. their pension cheques) with the Province carrying the larger portion of expenses. (The 2019 Operating Budget $15.9 million,  and shows Vancouver Coastal Health contributed $13.2 million dollars. The chief expense of course is labour. L.M.P. is a union shop. Approximately 120 staff are members of the Hospital Employees Union (H.E.U.)

An outbreak of COVID-19 was declared at Little Mountain on November 22, 2020.  Within very few days dozens of patients were crashing, and confined to their rooms on the second and thirds floors. The staff Director agreed to a conference call with families, arranged for December 7th. In the Zoom call she admitted that 59 were sickened and 5 had already died. A V.C.H.  doctor participated, and he praised the efficacy of ant-infection protocols that staff had been taught to adhere to. What wasn't admitted was that staff were becoming infected almost as fast as the residents. (70 staff have tested positive)  CTV News reported on December 16th, that 17 residents had died. The information derived from frightened and angry relatives, as the care home, the health authority, and government were not giving out death counts for specific homes.  Finally, Radio News 1130 was given access to the recorded conference calls, and on Christmas Eve, sounded the alarm.  93 residents had contracted the virus, and 31 were dead.

Most information on "the Little Mountain Disaster"** derives from Zoom conference calls that participants "leaked" to radio, television and print reporters. (Unless non-disclosure agreements were signed, I think the appropriate word is "provided". And thank God they did, or this whole disaster would have been stuffed down the Memory Hole, along with most of the history of Canada's first COVID-year.

** so dubbed in a story published by the South China Morning Post, of Hong Kong.

In a Zoom call convened on December 29th, a verbal summary was provided to families by Dr. Andrew Hurlburt, the designated "V.C.H. infection inspector."  Hurlburt who was as candid as he dare be,  admitted that "multiple infected staff" brought the disease into the facility.  The problem, he said, was that infected staff were either asymptomatic, or perhaps in the spirit of toughing it out for the benefit of their frail charges, showed up for work and did not report their symptoms.  Here Dr.  Hurlburt introduced a new term that we must add to our pandemic lexicon. "Presenteeism"is when a staff member, with all good intentions,  downplays medical symptoms, and shows up for work.

In the case of L.M.P. all of the residents were very old and infirm, and so 41 quickly died. All of the staff are of working age and healthy.  70 tested positive, but none died. Dr. Hurlburt described the disaster as a "perfect storm". Perhaps, but it was a storm the care home had nine months to prepare for, and 41  passengers should not have drowned.

Dr. Hurlburt says staff infected patients at Little Mountain - 41 Died

 

Dr. Bonnie Henry is Stung

Dr. Hurlburt's findings are what they are,  but if we are to have a public airing of the tragedy, it is only because the families turned to Ian Young, the Vancouver representative of the South China Morning Post,  Hong Kong's heavyweight English daily. Young spent the Christmas holidays digging, and his initial story appeared on New Year's Day. He reported that when he sat down with Angela Millar, the Director of L.M.P., he got the same treatment that had tormented the families.  Asked if the death toll  had risen to 31, as reported by NEWS 1130,  Ms. Millar stuck the lower number 17. "We've had four Zoom  meetings, so I don't  know which one you're referring to, but at the time we gave the information it was accurate."  With that Ms. Millar deflected the puck into the corner, referring Young to higher authority - Vancouver Coastal Health. 

After striding up the driveway at 330 East 36th Avenue, Ian Young turned for a last look before writing his story. "From the street, on a cold and rainy winter's evening on Wednesday, the only evidence of the outbreak was that most of the home's windows were ajar." In fact, in the upper floors men and women were still dying. Ten more (that we know of) would die after he stepped off the property. His article certainly caused a stir in Victoria, and it caused a few flak-catchers to pare down New Year plans.

Dr. Bonnie Henry is our Provincial Health Officer, and during our first COVID-year she achieved a level of public acclaim that rivals sainthood. She is our Mother Theresa. That reality was acknowledged by the New York Times which profiled Henry in June of 2020.  The Times published a photo of Dr. Henry posed beneath stained glass windows, the gaudy colours mottling her face and clothing.  The Little Mountain Disaster was dangerous for her, and she knew it. The S.C.M.P. story was solid and damning, and it was forcing our local media to take a closer look. 

At the scheduled press briefing on January 4,  Richard Zussman of Global Television  became the first reporter to take a direct shot on goal. He asked Dr. Henry why the province no longer released case and death counts for individual care homes, when those statistics "used to be provided daily". He emphasized "daily", and further asked at what point the Province might step ion and provide additional support to the ravaged senior's facility. 

She started by insisting that "there's been no change in policy", but then pivoted into a weak and convoluted claim that the surge in deaths during December had resulted in a decision to provide  "aggregate numbers" instead of making factual statements about casualties at individual outbreaks. A transcript of her explanation - "but as the number increased, the actual person power to get that information every day, and collate it, was taking hours, and hours, and hours of epidemiology time.  Um... because we do not have an IT system that allows us to do that efficiently, so we went top aggregate numbers." 

Dr. Bonnie Henry explaining missing data on COVID Deaths in BC Nursing Homes

If you want to understand just how dishonest was Dr. Henry's answer to Mr. Zussman's fair question, I invite you watch a few episodes of THE BEHAVIOUR PANEL on Youtube. The panel of four professional analysts is both informative and entertaining. (Recently they deconstructed the alibis of Carole Baskin, the female nemesis on Netflix's TIGER KING series.)  Better yet, if you want skills to apply in your own life, have a read of the 2012 book SPY THE LIE, written by veteran C.I.A. interrogators. The point of the exercise is not to tarnish Dr. Henry's reputation, but to challenge those with political power,  and demand they call a halt to hidden fiasco's, like hiding the ghastly death counts among our most vulnerable seniors. 

 GENUINE DATA AT LAST

Ian Young followed up, on January 8th, with an even more thorough investigation of the L.M.P. disaster. Fortunately, Dr. Bonnie Henry had been stung, and somehow she (and Health Minister Adrian Dix) not only sorted out their "IT" problem,  but on January 7th they issued a splendid new information packet - a fifteen page summary entitled Weekly COVID-19 Outbreak Report for Long-Term Care, Assisted Living and Independent Living Facilities, January 7, 2021. Up until now the news agencies were only given the names of nursing homes ravaged by the Flu, but no details. (The first COVID outbreak in B.C. was in the Lynn Valley Lodge, in March of 2020,) This document has details for 51 locations.  It remains to be seen if B.C. Health will continue to fess up, or if the  numbers will bounce around.  I had been collecting the monthly report of the B.C. Vital Statistics Agency all through 2020, and with each publication, the data was bouncing around. I will comment on what the numbers tell us,  in a future article.

As a public historian, I care about the creation of a permanent factual record of our shared pandemic experience. "Power" is concentrated in the hands of only a few hundred people in this Province, and they are responsible for all permanent outcomes. This article is a tale of two nursing homes, which shared 70 deaths in the space of only a few days. The big question I would ask, because of how the the COVID-narrative was spun over ten months, is how many of those 70 patients went to hospital I.C.U.s, and how many were simply made as comfortable as possible, and allowed to die in their residential units? That information, where the victims died, was not given in the data-drop.  **

** In the UK for example, the Office For National Statistics separates COVID deaths into four piles - "HOSPITAL, CARE HOME, HOME, OTHER" - extracting fact from Official death Certificates.

 

Here is the extracted  data for Little Mountain Place (Vancouver) and for AgeCare Harmony Court,  (Burnaby) dated January 7, 2021:

 

 

 

Chris Campbell, over at the BURNABY NOW, was quite blunt in his reaction to the B.C. Government's sudden launch of a weekly account of COVID-carnage in care homes. "The B.C. government finally stepped in this week where some health authorities have (deliberately) fallen down when it comes to more detailed data on COVID-19 outbreaks".  Mr. Campbell has a personal interest in forcing the NDP Government to be mores responsive to terrorized families. He revealed in an article published in 2020 that his own 83-year-old mom was a resident in a care home, and he was frightened for her. Because he is a newsman, he is perceived to have influence. "Many of those family members have literally begged me to write about the care homes since the pandemic began. They wanted to raise the alarm about the situation to force more action."

 

Just before Christmas I heard a ranking union official claim that the solution to Corona-virus deaths among the vulnerable elderly, was to unionize "all"  nursing homes and assisted living facilities in British Columbia. If you consult the magazine published by the H.E.U. you will find commentary on how this Flu Pandemic is providing organized labour a golden opportunity to enlarge the membership, and go after the "For Profit" facilities.  The Little Mountain Disaster provides concrete evidence that deadly contagions do not respect union cards, nor would the rank and file benefit from attempts at making direct comparisons. The urgent solution, as Dr. Hurlburt found at Little Mountain,  is 100% adherence to safety protocols. Many non-union caregivers are already achieving that level of competence.

 

Edward Snowden lands at Metrotown

The Edward Snowden memoir, PERMANENT RECORD, has safely landed at Metrotown Mall, and that is good news. As some of you may know, the American Government wants this man dead, and because they failed to prevent publication of this book, they are now trying to use their courts to seize all author royalties. I sought to locate a copy, so on Sunday I made my way to the INDIGO bookstore. The mall was exceptionally crowded, and the parking decks packed solid. There were easily 200 people in the bookstore itself, a few even buying books. A helpful staffer escorted me to the display I was seeking. (photo below)

from

The store has only the hardcover edition, but it is discounted to an even $25 dollars, and that is well under the publishers suggested retail price. Oddly, the Canadian ISBN label (in photo above) categorizes PERMANENT RECORD under the bland phrase "Current Events".  No matter.

I don't know how many copies CHAPTERS - INDIGO has shipped to their Metrotown outlet, or how well it sells, but given the ferocious hostility of corporate media to Snowden's message, it is an accomplishment that the book even exists. It is deserving of a wide readership. The writing has been praised, and of course the story of Snowden's defection from the American Surveillance State is of incredible importance. He has proven himself an incredibly brave and altruistic man, whose revelations have confirmed our worst suspicions about U.S. intentions.

The most enthusiastic review I have read so far, appeared in THE GUARDIAN. Here is the LINK.

The Guardian declares the memoir "a gripping spy story". Much more accurate than "Current Events," don't you agree?

For those planning to just borrow a copy at the public library, I have checked availability for you. The Burnaby has purchased six copies for the system, and only two of those for the Metrotown Branch. Today there is a waiting list of 37 people for those six copies.

An extract from PERMANENT RECORD (pages 252-253) 
Edward Snowden describes his days of "War Driving".

 ARCHIVAL
 Part of the "permanent record" now includes the lawsuit undertaken by the American "Deep State".  Here are page 1 and page 14 of the Court Filing, dated September 17, 2019:

 and

and

Edward Snowden was the surprise guest on the JOE ROGAN podcast, October 23, 2019.  Snowden spoke for over two hours, and it was the most scintillating monologue I have heard in years.  I appreciated every word, and marvelled at how well organized are his Snowden's thoughts.  He is not only a heroic figure, but a highly intelligent and compassionate man. By merely walking around and breathing he is a symbolic threat to all politicians, business tycoons and uniformed thugs who "govern" the diversity of nations on this planet.

2018 ELECTION COSTS - reporter forces secretive BURNABY to reveal spending figures

It was an editorial of genuine significance.  So important that I scraped it from the BURNABY NOW website, to share here.  Chris Campbell won't mind. He is a reporter at the NOW, and he worked with persistence to get us this astonishing information.  I am grateful, and so should you be.

"OPINION: I slogged through the Burnaby bureaucracy for 6 measly numbers"  Now and Then - September 14, 2019

Campbell begins his editorial by explaining that in January of this year he read in the Tri-Cities News a breakdown of civic election costs for Coquitlam, Port Moody and Port Coquitlam.  He brought this article to the attention of a city of Burnaby functionary, and explained that his paper would like to  provide a similar breakdown for the residents of this city. That was eight months ago.  After a push-pull session Chris Campbell was persuaded by municipal staff to "wait" until  a formal report was submitted to council.  As the months fell from the 2019 calendar, the reporter was told the report was "pending". He realized he was being stonewalled, but he waited.  An email last summer revealed that in fact,  "there would be no report coming on the election costs". 

All of this has been conducted by Email.   Then he received an official response "IN THE MAIL !" informing the BURNABY NOW that the email exchange was being taken as a formal ATIP request, and it had been forwarded to the city finance department.   On September 11, 2019 Mr. Campbell received a summary of figures for the 2014 and 2018 municipal elections,  "Via email".  As she put it, "You can't make this stuff up."  He was referring to games-playing, not the financial figures.

MUNICIPAL EXPENDITURE  (BURNABY)
ON THE  2018 CIVIC ELECTION

"Software (data fix):  $87,312
 Hardware (tabulators):  $95,947.03
 Voter cost and candidate information packages (print and postage):  $141,041.65 
 Staff costs - advance polling and day-of-polls:  $190, 104.18
 Other expenditures (compensation, supplies, etc) $494,693.46

 TOTAL  $1,009,098.32"

Of course that is the OFFICIAL taxpayer outlay.  The candidates had their individual, and shared campaign expenditures. Those were immediately forthcoming, as required by, and under penalty of the law.

The 2014 civic election also cost taxpayers more than a million dollars, and Mr. Campbell adds, "that's the price to be paid for democracy".  

 "DEMOCRACY" IN BURNABY
All in "the Family" 

Consider the following, scraped from news archives:

"Housing advocates stage three-hour 

sit-in in mayor's office"  BURNABY NOW,  March 9, 2017

The photo (below) shows Ivan Drury, a graduate student at SFU (History), occupying Mayor Derek Corrigan's office. Drury was one of the principle organizers of the "Stop Demovictions" campaign, and their efforts definitely got the media's attention during the 2018 Burnaby municipal election. Credit for ousting Mayor Corrigan goes not to the housing activists, or to the voters. Burnaby's most powerful politician was felled by former backers, a union faction that had been loyal to him for years. (It was a bloodless coup d'etat, if you will.) That said, the spectacle of Corrigan lynched by his own "brothers and sisters" in the Burnaby Citizens Association did focus the mind on what the B.C.A. is truly capable of. The BCA - CUPE cabal has run our city for as long as anyone can remember, and I expect it will always rule Burnaby. There is no way to oust a political machine that is in bed with its employees. The BCA and CUPE combine to protect each other against all potential opposition - editorial or electoral.  You cannot oust one, without ousting the other. 

Ivan Drury is an interesting fellow, and Burnaby politicians are not the only crew he has been screwing with. If you Google Mr. Drury  you will harvest a bushel basket of news coverage, and some of his  own political articles. He is a tireless organizer and has staged several effective protests. I think he has an acquired taste for unarmed political confrontation. Drury has even been arrested by the lads in Kevlar, and prudently surrendered himself to "lawful force".  In his essays he professes to hate "neo-liberal" politicians, those whose pro-diversity posture he considers phony. He labels them "philanthrocapitalists," or worse. As he is an advocate for the truly powerless in B.C., he has my respect. But when he visits Burnaby City Hall he must understand that he is confronting the truly powerful, and they are just as smart as he is.  They are not Drury's enemy at all.  They just need more time to free up tens of millions of taxpayer dollars, and quietly deal with "affordable housing", without triggering a ratepayer backlash that might cost them a few seats on council. They don't want any pesky freethinkers raising objections at Council meetings. The BCA concept of "Democracy" is essentially Maoist, as Mr. Corrigan recently found out.

What Housing Advocates like Ivan Drury will not acknowledge, while ranting and chanting about civic politicians being in the pockets of developers, is that the City of Burnaby (our example at hand) is itself the primary developer. The city makes the rules, skims heavily at the table, and decides who gets to play the game. The city profits on every project it allows to go forward, and never concerns itself with the fate of those "believers" who buy a ticket to ride the condo elevator. As we know, that elevator often stalls between floors, trapping more than a few. The Burnaby politicians, and their enablers, have demonstrated time-after-time that they shared lust for permanent control over this wealthy civic hive. Their concept of "Democracy" is dollar driven and utterly ruthless.  Derek Corrigan was certainly the Robert Mugabe of B.C.  politics, and nobody''s teddy-bear,  but it wasn't "the voters" who decided his fate. We were told that retired fireman Mike Hurley was an "Independent" candidate for mayor, nudge nudge, wink wink. It just happens that his union is one of the puzzle pieces that combine to complete that happy portrait of the prosperous B.C.A. "family".  Has any eavesdropper detected disharmony at City Hall?  Has a family councillor been called in to mediate between "Papa" Hurley and a united squad of NDP siblings? Of course not.

EATING THE WEALTHY CHINESE

After years of our burial in mind-numbing political rhetoric and baffle-gab, there seems no basis for a frank an open discussion of where Greater Vancouver thinks it is going. Individual sovereignty died here decades ago. Owning property is no longer a security for your old age. It is a responsibility to feed the beast. One question never asked is "Why... why do so many newcomers from Asia, allow white municipal governments to kick their teeth in, with those unbelievably extortionate levels of taxation and punitive penalties?" Such passivity boggles the mind.  The Chinese now exist in sufficient numbers here, that with just a little organization they could win elections and turf out the racist feather-beders who have us all by the throat. Yet they take the abuse. Astonishing. (Yes I know, every municipal regime in the GVRD has its temple dogs, (the BCA has a few) but that should not distract our attention from the faces of priestly class who runs these rigged civic elections.)

 While I am in sympathy with some of Mr. Drury's "eat the wealthy" credo,  he will ultimately realize that activism may gain him celebrity, but it won't kick start a revolution.  The primary weakness of all young firebrands is that they profess a deep a cynicism, and yet all of their solutions evidence a persistent belief in "the system". Here in Burnaby the NDP control all three levels of "democratic" government. The city council and mayor of Burnaby are all NDP loyalists, living in symbiosis with their funding unions. There is no dissenting voice in the council chamber. Not a one. What is "democratic" in all of THAT? The true cynics in Canada no longer vote, and we should all in fact continue to boycott a rigged game. (Approximately 1/3 of registered voters bothered to vote in the 2018 Burnaby civic election.) Mr. Drury is an historian, and he knows that despotic dynasties can only be toppled by revolution. Since that proposition is definitely off the table, all that is left to him, and to us, is pay our taxes like obedient serfs, and hide the cow and the chickens.  


"Burnaby approves Metrotown downtown plan
after raucous council meetiing"  CBC News July 25, 1917

In this photo (above) we see Ivan Drury and protesters disrupting a meeting of City Council.
Three RCMP officers stand alert,  ready to defend a chamber of democracy.  Elected office holders had discreetly absented themselves.

Chinese Black Tea - How to Enjoy a pot with Confidence

We Canadians should drink Chinese tea more often. Here in Burnaby we are fortunate to have access to some of the finest teas on the market, and yet how many of us hesitate to sample them?  In our home we like to boast that we have our own "Tea Museum". We get away with such incautious remarks because over the years many good friends have given us gifts of superb teas, some of them purchased at auction in Taiwan and China.  My favourite tea is Formosa Oolong, but in fact I like many varieties.  I am not competent to describe good tea, or to make recommendations, so I asked a friend to help me out. She writes well, and is also a photographer. So the photographs are hers too.

What if CONSUMER REPORTS magazine

tested Chinese Puer (Dark Tea)?

by Amethyst Yi Chen

The prices of Chinese teas can range from cheap to extremely expensive. For example, you can buy a box of Lipton Black Tea which contains 20 tea bags in Superstore for only $16. However, expensive teas can cost more than $2,000 or can be so extreme that you need to attend the auction for it. 

Do more expensive teas generally taste better? What are the factors behind the pricing of tea? It is worth understanding the pricing rationale, so that you can make a better purchasing decision. There are many types of tea available in the market, with each there are different ways to determine the quality. Therefore, we are going to mainly focus on the sheng Puer tea today. 

What is Puer?

There are two types of Puer tea – sheng Puer and shu Puer, which literally mean raw Puer and matured Puer, respectively. Each style begins with Puer Mao Cha (unfinished tea). To be considered a Puer, the tea leaves must be grown in Yunnan Province and must be from descendants of Da Ye Zhong (large leaf type). The leaves must also be dried in the sun. The difference between sheng and shu Puer is the processing methods for each. Sheng Puer is a style of Puer where Mao Cha is aged naturally over time. Aging here means a combination of oxidation and fermentation. On the other hand, Shu Puer is wherein Mao Cha is pile-fermented, a process known as wet piling. 

Products I am Tasting

Here is the list of sheng Puer that will be tested, sorting from low to high price:

David’s Tea Sheng Puer:$8.98 for 50g, one-year aged

Cha Le Aged Lotus Pu’er Loose 2007: $12 for 50g, 12-year aged

Cha Le Aged Sheng Pu’er Cake 2007: $180 for 357g (equivalent to $25 for 50g), 12-year aged

Yunnan Tingxiang Puer Cake 2015: $300 for 357g (equivalent to $42 for 50g), 4-year aged

Simao Yunnan Puer Cake, 2008 Limited Edition: $1300 for 400g (equivalent to $162 for 50g), 11-year aged

Whether it tastes nice or bad sometimes can depend on personal preference, but the quality of tea is strictly determined through inspecting the dried leaves, the tea liquor, and the spent tea leaves. 

Here is the process I am intending to follow for testing: I will take 4 spoonfuls of tea from each product, respectively, brewing with my Yixing clay teapot in 100℃water. Since Puer is not supposed to steep, I will pour the tea liquor to my cup with a funnel right away (in 5 seconds, or the tea will be too strong for tasting).  And before drinking the tea, I will observe and record the colour of each of the tea liquors and spent tea leaves. 

Dried leaves: 

Colour: As the tea ages, the colour of the tea leaves will turn from green to brown red. I can see that David’s Tea Sheng Puer andYunnan Tingxiang Puer Cake 2015 are relatively green, while the Cha Le Cha Le Aged Sheng Pu’er Cake 2007 and Simao Yunnan Puer Cake, 2008 Limited Edition have turned dark brown red. Although age is one of the pricing factors (the older, the more expensive), it is not the key indicator of good quality puer tea. 

Shape: High quality leaves are visually distinct. If you take a closer look at the leaves, they should ideally be whole and very indistinct. David’s Tea Sheng Pueris comparatively fragile and powdery – a signal of low end Puer. 

Aromas: Older Puer tea smells more fragrant even when they’re dry. Among all the products, Yunnan Tingxiang Puer Cake 2015 andSimao Yunnan Puer Cake, 2008 Limited Edition have the best aromas. Tingxiang, like its literal meaning in Chinese, smells like flower fragrance. This could be because the leaves came from a tree which was surrounded by flowers. The Simao Yunnan Puer Cakehas a natural wood-scent, which is a commonly seen in high end Puer. 

Tea Liquor:

Colour: Instruction in David’s Tea Sheng Puersaid it should be steeped for 4-5 minutes; however, the authentic way to brew Puer is not to steep at all. I followed the traditional way to brew David’s Tea Sheng Puer(pour the tea to an empty cup in 5 seconds). The colour of the tea liquor is very light – pale yellow – so I expected it to taste like water.  Cha Le Aged Lotus Pu’er Loose 2007 showed a dark brown colour but looked relatively muddy. The tea liquor of Tingxiangis like orange yellow, which is commonly seen in 3-5-year aged Puer tea. Simao Yunnan Puer Cake, the most expensive tea on the list, proves that it is worth the price. This 11-year aged tea shows a crystal-clear garnet colour. 

Aromas: Just as how I mentioned in the dried leaves section, the Tingxiang Puer Cakeand Simao Yunnan Puer Cakehave the best aromas in their tea liquor. 

Tasting: Generally, the taste of sheng Puer should be smooth, with slight hints of bitterness. It can also be woody or earthy. The taste can change as the tea ages, so sometimes it is hard to judge if the tea is considered a top grade through tasting. As long as it is mellow and smooth, not tightening your throat (some low-end teas do!), I will consider it ok. More importantly, the special feature about Puer is its sweet aftertaste, called “hui gan” in Chinese. It means that once the bitter sensation of the tea liquor is gone, the sweet aftertaste appears in the mouth. Unlike other types of tea, the aftertaste of Puer is generally long-lasting. For top graded tea, you can feel the liquor down the throat rather than just on the tongue. 

Among the five products I am tasting, Simao Yunnan Puer Cake, 2008 Limited Edition has the strongest and longest aftertaste (hui gan), leaving a nice “feeling” in the back of the throat. Tingxiangtastes a combination of sweet and bitter and also has a nice aftertaste. Generally, teas with good aftertaste and a thickness of flavour generally do better over time. Therefore, if we store Tingxiangproperly (dried and neutral) for an extra few years, it will definitely taste even better. David’s Tea Sheng Puerhas the least strong taste – I can barely taste it. 

For best results prepare the tea in an unglazed earthenware pot.

Affordable tea services are easy to find in Metrotown malls.

Spent Tea Leaves:

The condition of spent Leaves is one of the most important indicators of the quality. There are three factors to evaluate spent tea: tenderness, colour and the overall tea leaves shape.

Tenderness: Press the spent leaves with a finger – if they are soft and not elastic, then the tenderness is considered great. Based on this rule, here is the ranking of the tenderness, from good to bad: Yunnan Tingxiang Puer Cake 2015 >Simao Yunnan Puer Cake, 2008 Limited Edition >Cha Le Aged Sheng Pu’er Cake 2007. Note that the David’s Tea Sheng Puer and Cha Le Aged Lotus Pu’er Loose 2007 are comparatively crumbly, which I could not judge if they were tender. 

Colour: High quality of Young sheng Puer spent leaves usually appears bright yellow green. If you see dark green, or dark green leaves with red stems, that could be problematic. On the other hand, if aged sheng Puer shows bright red, then it is considered great. Among all the products, again, Tingxiang Puer Cake 2015and Simao Yunan Puer Cakehave the best colour. 

Evenness:
It is important to contemplate the overall evenness of spent tea leaves because high end tea leaves are very consistent in shape and colour. By that I mean, they will appear in about the consistent size of leaves and colour. As I mentioned, the David’s Tea Sheng Puerand Cha Le Aged Lotus Pu’er Loose 2007are crumbly and have large number of broken fragments. The rest of the teas are modest. 

Recommendations

In conclusion, Yunnan Tingxiang Puer Cakeand Simao Yunnan Puer Cakeperform the best in every respect of the testing. Simaois much more expensive than Tingxiang, but they are actually about the same level of quality. The reason that Simaois pricier is that it is 11-year aged while Tingxiangis only 4-year aged. With that being said, if the Tingxiang is also 11-year aged, they could have priced the same. Cha Le Aged Sheng Pu’er Cake 2007is considered okay. If you are a beginner with Puer tea, I would recommend you try this one first. However, I would not recommend David’s Tea Sheng Puer and Cha Le Aged Lotus Pu’er Loose 2007. 

Chinese and Taiwanese Movies on DVD - Borrow them at Burnaby Metrotown Library

For those who use such things, the automated  check-out system at the

Metrotown Branch of the Library. At the time it went operational, a

smiling staffer assured me that "not a single job was lost." I never

use it myself. The blue finger points to the Chinese media section.

TAX WEEK IN BURNABY

The line has been long this week at Burnaby City Hall, as many ratepayers enjoy the annual ritual of meeting their property taxes. For those who wait last minute, here is a tip. When you get as far as the elevator, don't forget to take off your hat, turn to the left and smile. Each taxpayer gets a photograph taken as we snail by. It won't be long until facial recognition software is added to the mix. I asked, and a nice lady at the counter assured me it was not installed yet... but maybe next year.  To amuse myself while waiting, I sorted memories of the past year, identifying the municipal services I receive for my generous contribution to city coffers.  One certainly has to be the DVD lending collection at the Metrotown Library, which I partake of several times per year.  I have a robust DVD collection of my own, but I enjoy viewing and studying foreign film, and the Criterion editions are just too expensive for a single viewing. The library has most, if not all of the movies known as the  Criterion Collection.

Superb Lending Collection -

Chinese and Taiwan DVDs

The Burnaby library collection of movies, documentaries and television series on DVD is truly massive, and if you love watching quality video, you certainly must spend an hour familiarizing yourself with what is available for borrowing. (This is an example your tax dollars at work!) I used to have favourite shops I enjoyed visiting and purchasing from, but very few local retailers continue to stock DVDs. Our library system purchased most of the DVD catalog from C & L Multimedia, a  family business that has become the leading supplier in Greater Vancouver. They also supply the U.B.C. and S.F.U. campuses. Both of those universities have film-studies  programs.

The collection is on the main floor, but I must point out that a special collection of Chinese and Taiwanese DVDs has been assembled, and it is shelved with the Asian books and magazines, in the n.e. corner of the building. I took a photograph this week to accompany this introduction to the service.  I do not know how much of the collection is currently out on loan, but it was very easy for me to fins a couple of movies to enjoy this week.

The best way to show what you can expect to find in this China - Taiwan DVD Collection  is to describe the two movies I borrowed and watched this past week.

BLIND SHAFT 盲井 is a Chinese crime-drama directed by Li Yang 李杨. The story, released in 2003,  unfolds in an extremely interesting, and also quite ugly, rural landscape that you may have read about in the news. There exists in China a very dangerous  archipelago of quasi-legal coal mines, most of which are notorious for exploiting poor migrant labourers, often to the point of death. This is an amazing film that was shot in a working coal mine, and on the streets of a miserable mining town. The packaging notes quote a review in The Village Voice that described BLIND SHAFT as "Part neorealistic expose, part noir thriller." That is actually a rather accurate summation of Li Yang's modus. A superb film!

STRAY DOGS 郊遊 is a 2013 Taiwan film that I had read about, and was thrilled to discover in the Metrotown Library collection. As I once lived and worked in Taiwan, I have an acquired taste for its national cinema, and I even have a couple of Tsai Ming-Liang's movies at home. But STRAY DOGS caught me off guard. I was not prepared for the intensity of my response to its principle ideas and its carefully constructed images. I take movies quite seriously and usually watch good films alone. As per habit, I immediately started imposing on family and friends, because an encounter with visual story-telling at this level, is something we often continue to process, in part by describing it to others.   I could give the story away in a paragraph, but that would be a cultural sin.  I expect to sit to a second viewing later this summer, if only to test my lasting impressions.

"THE EIGHT HUNDRED"
Political prejudice has delayed
China's best movie of 2019.

Chinese war movies seem to exist in only two varieties.  A quality production that tells a story well, or botch that is a total waste of time. NETFLIX is currently running a Chinese war film that is so bad, Bruce Willis should donate his pay-cheque to charity. AIR STRIKE  (2018) is ghastly, and Willis' performance is nothing short of an insult to cinema. By way of contrast, I am expecting great things from THE EIGHT HUNDRED,  a large-budget production that is a vivid (and admittedly embellished) retelling of one of the great Chinese victories of the Sino-Japanese War. In history it serves a similar function for China as Dunkirk did for Britain only a few years later. It was a defining moment of  sacrifice and patriotism that has actually been an inspiration to folks on both sides of the Taiwan Strait.  

The Battle of the Sihang Warehouse, was a rear-guard action conducted by a picked battalion. The Japanese has flanked the Chinese defensive line and were poised to overrun the Chinese half of Shanghai in 1937.  You may not have heard of it, but the brave stand on Soochow Creek was a notable  battle of its day, and well-covered by the British and American newsreel cameramen, who were filming from vantage points in the Foreign Settlements. In fact, the opposite side of the creek was British territory, and three men of the Royal Welch Fusiliers were killed during the Japanese assault. The story of the so-called  "doomed battalion" has been covered by four previous Asian movies made between 1938-1975 - one each made in China, Hong Kong, Taiwan and Japan. The Japanese rarely credited the Chinese army with having  credible combat skills, but they were forced to admit that the defence of Sihang Warehouse had been exceptional. The Japanese Naval Landing Force suffered 200 dead, compared to only ten Chinese defenders. Japan cinema in the 30s was experimenting with social realism, and it was films like "A Naval Brigade of Shanghai" (1939) that proved too much for the Nippon government to stomach. Film censorship ensued.

Allegory in a wartime propaganda poster.

We see China savagely tortured by an army 

of Lilliputians - Japanese Naval Infantry.

This 2019 rendition is expected to become the definitive account and it is definitely a Hollywood-style action picture. In fact several American experts were hired to do  a breakout of action sequences, and several foreign actors have speaking roles.  The official movie trailer shows that the combat is not limited to "the stand" inside the row of concrete warehouses, but spills  into the streets of Shanghai and the sky above. That allows for a truly massive body count on both sides.

Unfortunately the movie's opening at the Shanghai International Film Festival has been cancelled, due to naked political prejudice.  Some whiny communist committeemen are interfering with the release, and may even demand heavy censorship before THE EIGHT HUNDRED gets out of limbo. They just cannot live with the fact that the hero soldiers commanded by their "class enemies" were serving in the Koumintang's National Army, and it was the Sun flag dramatically hoisted in defiance of Japanese assault troops, not the Red flag.  If this nonsense persists, the money spent in promotion will be pissed away, and the film will lose momentum. It was just announced that the films premiere, scheduled for July 6, has been cancelled. We China film fans may end up, oh the irony!, of having this movie debut in North America not on big screens, but on NETFLIX.   

The official trailer for  THE EIGHT HUNDRED

is found onYoutube - HERE. 

Metrotown Murder Case - DNA DRAGNETS ARE HERE TO STAY

DNA-SPYING JUGGERNAUT

I started paying attention to DNA analysis about fifteen years ago, when I read an article describing how a Seattle high school was teaching basic DNA sequencing. I thought, "Fantastic! Their first hire might still be minimum wage, but at least they avoid a dead-end job, like flipping hamburgers." Then in 2012, I read a very credible report that American spooks were secretly collecting the DNA of all foreign leaders, while going to extraordinary lengths to clean up after Barack Obama. Secret Service duties included denying foreign enemies any opportunity to collect his DNA - hair, saliva, semen, skin flakes, etc. [Obama's original, signed and dated, birth registration in Hawaii was secured with equal vigilance.] Our American cousins had "weaponized" DNA, as they do with almost everything they touch. What Washington may do with the Trudeau DNA is anyone's guess, but the Canadian government has failed to warn our citizens about the perils awaiting those who volunteer DNA samples to the Yanks. That is a dereliction, or it is a leakage of their own intentions. 

One month ago I collected a chat-string that was archived on an open Facebook site. Their topic was, personal experience with the DNA Testing kits sold by ANCESTRY.Com and 23andMe. Of the 76 comments in the chat-thread, half offered a verdict on DNA test results. The group was a split between the 'Satisfied" or 'Sceptical'. Several of the disappointed consumers had clearly been influenced by what they learned from an investigation conducted by the MARKETPLACE program on the CBC television network: DNA ANCESTRY TESTS. They now understood they had wasted their money.

What I expected to read, but did not, was some mention of two 'good news' stories from 2018, filed by CBC reporters. One case involved two half-brothers in New Brunswick, men in their 80s who did not know they shared a father. It was a curious niece who initiated the DNA test. The other case was of two sisters, also in their 80s, who had been separated by adoptions. Recently they were re-united as a result of DNA test results injected into the genealogy Internet data-stream. Testimonials sell product and I note ANCESTRY has a SALE on this Canada Day week.

 In this recent video, Canadian journalist James Corbett

does not mince words. "Took an Ancestry DNA test? You

might be a 'genetic informant' unleashing secrets about

your relatives. Corbett's video is available HERE.

The CBC MARKETPLACE investigation, in consultation with accredited experts, identified a number of problems with the basic science used by the heavyweights in the DNA testing business, as well as questionable business practices. The show's dramatic narrative was its insistence on an explanation for how the five testing companies could generate widely divergent reports on identical twins, the Agro sisters. The team at Yale University who evaluated the five DNA reports insist the results should be uniform, if they hope to be deemed credible science.

Program length and the limits of viewer engagement, forced CBC journalists to concentrate on two key points. 1) The sequenced DNA from the Agro twins was compared to reference sets (the largest sets include millions of samples) assembled from people who originate from all inhabited regions of the world. Unfortunately each company creates its own approximation of the borders of ethnic regions. Their choices are "arbitrary" and this will cause "discrepancies" when two or more DNA reports are compared. 2) Sample-to-set comparisons are only made possible by the use of custom algorithms, and each company uses proprietary software. "The way [each of] these calculations are run is different." What the consumers are paying for are low resolution scans that produce little more than an "ethnicity estimates," which will in fact change over time as the reference sets increase in size. If you choose to become pen-pal with a far-distant stranger whose DNA correlates with your own, that's a bonus.

The CBC report failed to address a dangerous situation that is now an open-secret. Several U.S. companies that started out selling access to their genealogy databases, for a fixed monthly fee, have now morphed into billion-dollar DNA testing labs, intent on making huge profits selling client genetic data to "Big Pharma" and to all Law Enforcement and Spy Agencies who come calling. 

DNA testing revealed the "Golden State Killer" was former-cop Joseph James DeAngelo.

His courtroom expressions of contempt - scowls and grimaces, made his menacing mug as 

familiar as Freddy Krueger. Several artfully-staged press conferences in 2018 rendered 

Mr. DeAngelo the designated POSTER BOY FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT GENOMICS.

THE "GOOGLE OF GENOMICS"

We are just beginning to understand the ramifications of "surveillance capitalism" - emerging economies dependant on the commercial exploitation of digital oceans of behavioural data. What began with the seduction of the gullible onto the Social Media platforms, was just a bit of foreplay compared to the promised capabilities of the 5G network connecting the "Internet of Things". We are actually expected to applaud Orwellian tidings of a mad, mad world in which even the marriage-bed will be configured to record individual performance and levels of satisfaction, and relay that hot and desirable data stream to the corporate gods. The Internet Tycoons of tomorrow will anticipate our every mood and desire, processing the data generated by cities populated by two-legged lab rats. The Silicon Valley Billionaires created this dangerous behemoth for their benefit, not ours. Trillionaires and governments will merge in the new "surveillance economy".

Google is the 'gold standard' for companies that currently trades a "free service" of dubious value, for unlimited usage of personal data. The 'platinum standard' will be established by that company which is first to offer whole genome sequencing, free of charge. Imagine how the suckers will line up for a "free" sequencing - their complete genetic makeup on a single DVD. Information they do not understand and cannot use, a plastic token in exchange for corporate ownership and unlimited use of their genetic information.

Millions of us will be horrified by these predictions, and some consider resisting. The softening up process involves false promises and outright lies. Who hasn't heard this one: "The families of the wrongfully convicted deserve justice." Perhaps, but one man's freedom should never be dependant on fingerprinting and gene-printing an entire nation. Totalitarianism is not an antidote for a broken judicial system. In 2018 there was an avalanche of hype about the potential for solving "cold cases", using DNA databases. Police agencies and DNA experts held joint press conferences but offered few facts about what is really going on. ANCESTRY.COM, which is now the leading for-profit genealogy company in the world, (the Government of Singapore is an equity stakeholder) is privately held and therefore does not have to disclose much. ANCESTRY has though, boasted of its stockpile of DNA data, the fruit of fifteen million processed DNA kits. They further claim that in 2018 ANCESTRY handled only ten requests for cooperation with law enforcement. All those legal orders concerned credit card fraud and identity theft. Such companies let "Cold Case" stories "sell" the public on the concept of mass DNA sampling, but all such programs (Corporate and Law Enforcement) are forward-looking. The past is only incidental.

THE FBI PLUMBERS ARE BACK

In the 1930s J. Edgar Hoover ran aggressive media campaigns pushing his creepy idea of families voluntarily registering fingerprints with the FBI - "for their own benefit". Today it is your genetic fingerprints the FBI seeks, and they will not scruple to ask for them. Years ago the FBI went rogue, developing and deploying software enabling covert access to any common computer or. "The Bureau" has become a massive Intelligence Agency operating globally, and it is has the staff and budget to collect data it expects to need in the future. It will use DNA archives built today to enforce laws that do not even yet exist, and to destroy foreign opponents of the American Empire. In that dystopian future it will be a serious crime to seek simple privacy, because "stealing" data-flow from government and corporations will equate with theft of money.

You may remember the televised-trial of the "Golden Gate Killer" in 2018. Joseph James DeAngelo was an ex-cop turned serial killer and rapist, who evaded detection for decades. It was only when detectives tapped into the capabilities of commercial genomics websites that the case was cracked. By identifying and targeting a dozen distant relatives, investigators tracked back and arrested a shadowy fugitive killer, by then a 72 year old man. The media, predictably, played up the case and the public swallowed everything they were told. In fact public opinion polls helped solidify the idea that the public fully supported "DNA dragnets" as a necessary law enforcement methodology. Legislators went to work, and starting in California, added DNA swabbing to fingerprinting, at time of booking the accused. Worse, police officials everywhere, including Canadian sleuths, placed hands over hearts and swore an inability to conceive of doing their job without access to large-scale genome archives, coupled with the best technology available. It is already projected that within five years, the FBI (and RCMP?) will deploy mobile DNA sequencing technology to the crime scene, and retrieve a preliminary match within minutes. Of course any such curbside-DNA test will implicate a large number of people, all related by blood.

What you don't know, because it is not openly publicized, is that the FBI has been helping itself to commercial genome databases for some time. Their intrusion was exposed because in one case the purloined genome files, formatted in an unusual way, gave the data-thieves trouble. The Bureau phoned the offices of FamilyTreeDNA and boldly demanded free access. The company CEO, in an interview with FORENSIC MAGAZINE revealed that he was threatened with "a virtually endless succession of subpoena after subpoena" if he would not grant open access. The company caved.

Lex Calla has put together a short Youtube that will take

you through the Marrisa Shen (申小雨) story. It is HERE.

BURNABY IN TURMOIL 2017-18

Here in Burnaby, the benefits of an ethnically diverse community are very apparent. We all enjoy living here, and (gasoline taxes aside) there is is little to complain about. My wife is an active member and supporter of a Chinese temple in Metrotown, and there is a well-attended mosque two blocks from our home. Newcomers tend to want and need traditions such as religion, much more than do the greying generation of Canadians. Generally speaking, everyone gets along. Still, incidents do occur. Take the case of Marissa Shen, a young Chinese who was murdered on July 18, 2017 in Central Park, Metrotown. Her killing traumatized this city, and public safety became a hot-button local issue during the last election cycle. At the time the 13-year old was killed, I was one of those who jumped to conclusions. A good friend of mine who provides counselling to many newcomer families who struggle to adapt, had described the support given the Shen family before the girl's murder. (Marrisa was actually quite typical of girls her age and background.) My assumption was she had simply encountered a cunning fox on Social Media, and had considered the nearby park a safe arena. (Kids these days think they are invulnerable.) An intensive DNA Collection Dragnet proved me wrong, but police tactics rang alarm bells that should trouble you too.

DNA DRAGNET  IN  B.C.  TARGETS
MIDDLE-EASTERN  REFUGEE MALES

The only thing the American news industry loves more than a mass-shooting incident, is a complex serial killer investigation. Speculation, investigation, the take down, and a court room drama. A clever killer is better than Crazy Glue for keeping bums in seats, faces fixed on millions of flat screen TVs.  In August of 2018 the latest sensation was Joseph James DeAngelo, the so-called Golden State Killer, who was arraigned in August 2018.  DNA testing had been a constant factor in the investigation for almost twenty years,  first implicating and then exonerating many suspects. Then, in January of 2018, detectives tried something different - they uploaded DNA evidence to the website of GEDmatch, an "open source" archive of results collected primarily from family history enthusiasts. Bingo! Genealogical DNA identified almost twenty distant relatives of the elusive rapist-murderer, all of whom instantly fell under intensive investigation. The track-back to DeAngelo was easy. The decades old mystery was cracked and Mr. DeAngelo instantly became, what I fairly term,  The Poster Boy for Law Enforcement Genomics.  [Ref: Sacramento Bee article "'Open-source' genealogy provided missing DNA link to East Area Rapist, Investigator Says "]

Up here in Burnaby, Canada,  law enforcement agencies were under equally intense pressure to solve the murder of a young Chinese immigrant - Marrisa Shen.  The precise moment our local police bosses signed contracts with PARABON NANOLABS is still their secret, but the Shen case was clearly a test-bed for sleuthing methods that have forever changed how our cops go about their business. What we are currently witnessing is a perfect storm of privacy-obliteration.  The marriage of  two immensely powerful and insatiable beasts, on the one hand BIG intrusive governments and on the other, GREEDY immoral corporations. In the very near future, as high-speed DNA matching is added to the ubiquitous data-matching (ie. spying) routinely conducted by our federal, provincial and even municipal governments across Canada. In the future your family DNA profile will be matched not only against samples taken from murder and rape suspects, but to investigate such mundane "crimes" as real estate speculation and the surreptitious dumping of trash. Here in B.C., such Orwellian measures are being considered. Over in Toronto, condo associations are already forcing pet owners to register DNA, simply to catch pesky poopers.

A suspect in the Shen murder was arrested on September 7, 2018. He was identified as  Ibrahim Ali, a Syrian refugee who had been sponsored for entry into Canada by a Vancouver Christian church. The unmarried Syrian male had been here less than three months before he murdered a child in a Burnaby public park. RCMP - IHIT held a televised press conference three days later. A police spokesperson praised "our many partners [who] worked tirelessly for over a year to find answers", and offered a few statistics ... more than 1,300 residents near the crime scene canvassed, over 600 interviews conducted, over 2000 persons of interest identified and subsequently eliminated, and over 1000 hours of video image collected from 60 locations. The significant "notable partner" NOT named at the presser was the American genomics company PARABON NanoLabs. The role of that co-investigator, or details of the contract may come out in the trial. We can know about Paragon in advance, because a defence lawyer, who had access to the evidence and who spoke to CBC NEWS, spilled a trade name. "The analysis is called DNA phenotypic - also known as "Snapshot DNA" (see graphic above) - and it has provided leads and arrests in several cold cases in the United States by helping investigators predict the appearance or even ethnicity of a suspect." Here is a promotional graphic for the SNAPSHOT KINSHIP INFERENCE model.

It was Cornelia Naylor, an intelligent reporter, who uncovered the story of how RCMP - IHIT had really broken the case. "Marrisa Shen investigators may have done DNA sweep of Middle Eastern Men - BURNABY NOW, November 13, 2018. The local television affiliates of CTV and CBC followed her lead, and within a week it was out in the open. The DNA Dragnet had been nothing short of kick-ass. "The NOW has learned numerous Middle Eastern men living in the Lower Mainland - some of whom came to Canada to escape persecution in totalitarian regimes - were called up seemingly randomly and asked to provide voluntary DNA samples in relation to the killing." Soon individual Syrians and Kurds spoke to reporters, and it became very clear that none of the 2000 men who "volunteered" DNA samples did so unwillingly. What else can one do? Burnaby resident Ayub Faek asked "Why me?" He was assured, "Not only you. Many people." Our federal troopers have the guns, our governments their 24/7 electronic surveillance programs, and our society its reputation for yielding to all that coercive power without a whimper. We get, what we are going to get. And often.

JUST THE BEGINNING

I still recall some of the more naive comments shared on that FACEBOOK chat page, and I wonder if they will ever understand what they have stumbled into. But it was a CBC report that gave some urgency to my research. "Vancouver Police using same DNA technique that caught suspected Golden State Killer" - CBC May 30, 2019. "For the first time, a Canadian police force has confirmed it's using the same genetic genealogy technique that finally caught the suspected Golden Gate Killer, to solve a cold case of it own. Vancouver police have hired U.S. firm Paragon NanoLabs to search all available genealogical records in hopes of finding any link to a suspected miller's DNA. ... Parabon scours public genealogical sites such as GEDmatch and FamilyTreeDNA, which allow police to access their databanks. Most other well-known DNA testing companies don't cooperate with law enforcement without search warrants." 

Did you catch that? The American contractor will search "all available genealogical records".  Over 2000 immigrant men in Greater Vancouver, many of them refugees from war zones,  have just had their first encounter with a DNA Dragnet. Their personal genomes are now locked inside databases that will be consulted and matched against the records provided by millions of people who are determined to play with things they do not understand.   What once existed only in the realm of Dystopian fiction is now our reality.  And as Orwell made so very clear in his prophetic work, NINETEEN EIGHTYFOUR,  the precious freedoms the "Prols" surrender to Big Brother, they will never, ever get back.

The bitter irony in all this?  Over 2000 entirely innocent immigrant men have been aggressed against by the Canadian state.  Each will respond to that aggression in their own way. All responses are entirely understandable. Worse, not a single detective or crime lab boffin will have regrets about perpetrating those acts of aggression against innocent parties. They are proud exponents of state power, they relish that power, and they covet even more intrusive capability.   As to the suffering of the Shen family, who are the greatest victims of the "refugee system", which is a political process, they have no recourse. The trial of Ibrahim Ali will soon get underway, and we will learn nothing useful from that process.